Home › Guides › Too many insurance calls

Why Am I Getting So Many Health Insurance Calls? (And How to Stop Them)

SmartHealthMatch team · Reviewed by a licensed health insurance advisor · Updated September 2026

In short: One quote form can be sold, resold, and dialed by dozens of companies. In August 2025 the FTC showed how big that machine is. Here is how it works, which opt-out steps actually help, and how to shop without it.

Prefer to talk? (269) 953-2357 — a licensed advisor, not a call center · 7 days, 8 a.m.–10 p.m. ET

Licensed advisors in 48 states · license details on our disclosures page · one advisor per person, never a call list · not a government site — marketplace plans are also at HealthCare.gov or your state marketplace

You typed your ZIP code and phone number into one health insurance website. By dinner you had eleven missed calls, three voicemails from companies you had never heard of, and a text asking you to "confirm your enrollment." If that sounds familiar, you are not imagining it and you did not do anything unusual. You ran into an industry that is built to turn one inquiry into many phone calls, and in 2025 federal regulators put hard numbers on how large it is.

This guide explains where the calls come from, what the Federal Trade Commission found when it went after two of the biggest players, which opt-out tools stop which calls, and how to keep shopping for coverage without handing your number to a call list.

Get real numbers for your ZIP — free, from one licensed advisor →

The short answer: your number became a product

Most of the calls trace back to lead generation. A lead is simply a record about a person who might buy something: name, phone, ZIP code, age, sometimes income or health details. Health insurance leads are valuable because a single enrolled customer can pay an agent or call center a commission for years, so buyers compete for fresh ones.

Many sites that look like neutral quote tools are really lead collectors. Their business is not quoting you a plan; it is selling the record you just created. Depending on the site's terms, that record may be sold once ("exclusive"), sold to several buyers at the same moment ("shared"), or auctioned in real time to whoever bids highest. Some buyers then resell it again, a practice often called aging or re-marketing. We walk through the mechanics of the checkout page itself in why quote sites sell your number. This page is about the scale and about getting the calls to stop.

What the FTC found in 2025

On August 7, 2025, the FTC announced settlements totaling $145 million with two companies in the under-65 health insurance marketing business. The complaints are allegations the companies settled, not court findings, but the documents describe the call problem in unusual detail.

Source: FTC press release, "Assurance IQ and MediaAlpha to Pay a Total of $145 Million to Settle FTC Charges That They Misled Consumers Seeking Health Insurance," August 7, 2025; MediaAlpha Form 8-K, August 6, 2025. Checked September 28, 2026.

Put that 119 million figure next to the U.S. adult population and the point is plain: the volume of leads moving through this system is enormous, and a single quote form is enough to put you inside it. The FTC also alleged that the leads were auctioned to other lead generators and telemarketers, which is why many of your callers seem to have no connection to the site you actually visited.

Why the calls come in waves

The pattern most people describe has three stages, and knowing them helps you judge whether the flood is ending or just shifting.

• Minutes 1 to 60: the live-lead rush. Buyers pay the most for a lead that is minutes old, so auto-dialers call immediately and repeatedly. This is the burst of back-to-back calls and texts.
• Days 2 to 30: the shared-lead tail. Buyers who purchased the same record work it on their own schedules. Calls come from new names and new local-looking numbers, because caller ID can be spoofed.
• Months later: aged leads. Older records are resold cheaply, often to callers with the least to lose. A spike around open enrollment is common, because that is when buyers restock. For 2027 coverage, HealthCare.gov open enrollment runs November 1, 2026 through January 15, 2027 (see our 2027 open enrollment dates by state), so expect more calls from late October on.

Not every caller is a scammer. Some are licensed agents who bought a lead in good faith. But you cannot tell from the ring which kind you have, and the least careful buyers make the most calls. Our guide to spotting health insurance scams covers how to verify any caller's license in about two minutes.

Which opt-out tools stop which calls

There is no single switch that ends every call, because the law treats a stranger cold-calling you differently from a company you gave permission to. Here is what each tool does, based on the rules as of September 2026.

Sources: FTC, National Do Not Call Registry; FCC, TCPA consent revocation rules (effective April 11, 2025); 16 CFR 310.4 (Telemarketing Sales Rule). Checked September 28, 2026.

Two details are worth knowing. First, a broader FCC rule that would make one "stop" apply to every kind of message from the same company has been delayed, most recently to January 31, 2027, so for now a "stop" may only cover the type of message you answered. Second, the FCC tried to require that a consumer's consent go to one seller at a time, which would have gone straight at shared leads. A federal appeals court vacated that rule on January 24, 2025, days before it took effect, in a case brought by an insurance marketing trade group. So the tighter consent standard the FTC now imposes on MediaAlpha applies to that company through its order, not to the whole industry by rule.

A seven-day plan to quiet your phone

1. Register your number at donotcall.gov if you have not already. It is free and never expires.
2. Answer one or two calls on purpose. Ask for the company's full name and where it got your number. Then say clearly: "Put me on your internal do-not-call list and do not contact me again." Write down the date, time, and company.
3. Reply STOP to every insurance text. It is a recognized revocation keyword under the FCC rules.
4. Turn on your phone carrier's spam filter and your phone's option to silence unknown callers for a couple of weeks, while the live-lead rush dies down.
5. Report repeat offenders at donotcall.gov with the date, number, and company name. Calls that continue after you asked to stop are exactly what the complaint system tracks.
6. Check any "enrollment" claims before you respond. If a caller says you are enrolled in something, log in to your own marketplace account or call the official marketplace yourself. Unauthorized plan switching is a known scheme.
7. Do not fill out another quote form until you have read its consent line (next section). Each new form restarts the cycle.

Most people see a sharp drop within two to four weeks. Aged-lead calls may trickle in for months, and each "stop" you give removes one more caller.

How to shop without feeding the machine

You still need coverage, so the goal is not to avoid shopping; it is to shop through doors that do not sell your number.

• For marketplace plans, go direct. HealthCare.gov or your state's official exchange lets you browse plans and see your subsidy without handing your number to a lead buyer. For many households, especially anyone with a pre-existing condition or income under the 2026 subsidy line, a marketplace plan is often the strongest option.
• Read the words under the submit button. Phrases like "our marketing partners," "insurance companies, agents, and their affiliates," or a small link to a partner list mean your record may go to many buyers. Look for plain language that names who will contact you.
• Ask any advisor how they get paid. An honest answer is easy to give. Our guide on how health insurance agents get paid explains the commissions behind the calls.
• Know what you are being offered. Private underwritten plans can cost less for some healthy applicants, but they are not guaranteed issue and may limit or exclude pre-existing conditions. Short-term and limited-benefit plans, the products at the center of the 2025 Assurance IQ case, are not ACA coverage. Anyone who tells you otherwise on a cold call is a reason to hang up. See what "underwritten" means for the full picture.

Why SmartHealthMatch works differently

We built SmartHealthMatch as the opposite of a lead auction. When you complete the coverage check, your answers go to one licensed advisor, not to a list of buyers. We do not sell, rent, or share your information with other agents or call centers, and our privacy policy says so in writing. The advisor looks at both sides: marketplace plans with any subsidy you qualify for, and private underwritten options where they may fit. If the marketplace is the better deal for your household, that is what you will hear.

You can also skip the form entirely and call the number at the top of this page. Either way, one person, one conversation, and no flood of calls afterward.

Age 65 or older? This guide is about under-65 coverage. Medicare enrollment is at medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE.

Frequently asked questions